Just How Safe Are Those Mexican Trucks?
What happens when you have an administration that cares more about the free market than regulatory oversight? Poison spinach, toothpaste and pet food, lead in our kids’ toys, mortgage lending run amok and now unsafe trucks on our highways. The Teamsters biggest argument against the Department of Transportation’s dangerous Mexican Truck "pilot program" has always been about safety. The counter argument by supporters of this sham has been: "but the trucks are closely inspected and the companies are all thoroughly checked." Oh yeah? What about Trinity Industries de Mexico? Until a few weeks ago, this company and its 16 trucks were approved to operate on U.S. roads by Mary Peters’ inspectors. According to Teamster.org, the company pulled out of the program on Feb. 1, after it was discovered that Trinity received 1,123 safety violations in the year before the border was opened, or 112 violations per vehicle.
"Mary Peters has some explaining to do," said Jim Hoffa, Teamsters general president. "She claimed that she only opened the border to Mexican trucks after they passed rigorous safety inspections. Now we learn that Trinity Industries averaged 112 safety violations per truck -- according to the Transportation Department’s own statistics -- in the year before it was allowed to use American highways." Hoffa questioned whether it was a coincidence that Trinity dropped out of the pilot program shortly after a declaration was made to the federal court about the company’s many serious safety violations. The Teamsters, Public Citizen, the Sierra Club and the Owner-Operators Independent Drivers Association are challenging the legality of the cross-border pilot program in the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco. Oral arguments will be heard on February 12. |





Trinity's inspection records
I happened to check SafeStat's record for Trinity last week in response to someone who said their record didnt look that bad and was surprised to see how low the numbers had magically dropped overnight. I had looked at them when the teamsters and OOIDA first reported their bad record and I knew they were very different. One thing I noticed was it looked like there were a whole lot of very recent inspections. Something didnt look right.
So, I downloaded the entire record into excel, sorted them according to inspection record number and started counting: how can you inspect the same eight trucks over 40 times in one day-all with sequential report numbers? You cant blame that on Trinity-somebody within the DOT dummied up the record. If you add 40% MORE, clean inspections to the group, it lowers the percentage of bad reports considerably. If the Peters Gang is doing this kind of doctoring the record, I'd think it was at least 'contempt of Congress'!
As additional proof the entire record is false, either Trinity had nine trucks and only eight licence plate numbers, or the guy who copied and pasted the dummy records into the report got a 1-number typo in one VIN into the system and copied it in about fifteen places!
Although Trinity is no longer in the picture, if someone has falsified their inspection records, how can we be sure any of the records are remotely correct or believe anything the whole bunch of them say about monitoring, compliance or verification?
How do we get this to the attention of Congress and the American people?